About Us

About The Mystery Company

We are The Mystery Company and our specialty is hilarious interactive mystery theater. No one does it like us or as well as us. We blend together a superb theatrical performance with the excitement and fun of an interactive “Whodunit” murder mystery.

We perform for large groups and small and have played at every major hotel in the Rochester area and performed for Rochester’s largest corporations. We’ve been a key ingredient in sales meetings and conferences, and offer team building programs as well. We are known for our outstanding shows for fund-raising and our work with all types of organizations. We are a thrilling component of countless events and celebrations.

We’ve been enthralling Rochester and Upstate NY area audiences for 25 years. Our carefully crafted original scripts can take you anywhere and anytime. Expect the Unexpected but be prepared for an unforgettable and hilarious experience. TRUST NO ONE!

The Mystery Company’s distinguished credits include writing and performing historically based theater for organizations such as the George Eastman House, Susan B. Anthony House, and the Seaway Trail, Inc.

Join us for our scheduled events or we can create a murderously perfect performance just for your group, special occasion, or facility.

Murder Mystery Dinner Theatre Testimonials

- Becky Ross – Private Event

It was a night we will forever remember! Your cast was awesome and they did a fantastic job making everyone in the room a part of the story. Thanks so much for everything. We really didn't take any pictures during the show but took a few in the beginning during cocktails. When I get back home I will post these to your Facebook page.

Thanks again and you guys absolutely did exceed expectations.

It was a night we will forever remember! Your cast was awesome and they did a fantastic job making everyone in the room a part of the story.

- Kenneth A. Nelson, Chairman of RIMES – Corporate

Please let your crew know that everyone is talking about how great the event was. Even Duncan Brown, who doesn't come to many of our events said this this was the best time he has had in a long time. You have a great group and I will spread the word to others that may want to do a program like this for their group. Have a great holiday season.

Please let your crew know that everyone is talking about how great the event was.

- Pattie Taylor Brown, All Occasions Catering

You guys ROCK! The audience was absolutely INTO the fun and shenanigans that The Mystery Company introduced! You turned a fun party into a GREAT one, thank you! We will definitely use The Mystery Company again - and often!

The audience was absolutely INTO the fun and shenanigans that The Mystery Company introduced! You turned a fun party into a GREAT one.

- Jenna Deegan, Grand Lady Cruises

Our experience with the Mystery Company has only exceeded our expectations. The actors' enthusiasm is contagious as they really go above and beyond to make sure all guests are comfortable and enjoying themselves.

The actors' enthusiasm is contagious as they really go above and beyond to make sure all guests are comfortable and enjoying themselves.

- Marianne - Private Event

We had a ball and have heard several people say they think this was the best party we ever had. A group of us stood at the coffee pot for about ½ hour reliving the evening. We will definitely keep The Mystery Company in mind for a future party.

Private Events

For Venues

Corporate Events